Lawyers clash with AG over genocide deal

Claudia Bröll
Lawyers from Germany and Namibia are considering filing a lawsuit in a Namibian court to have the legality of a joint declaration by the two countries reviewed.

They are acting on behalf of a Namibian member of parliament and an Ovaherero and Nama genocide organisation.

Lawsuits have been filed before, but in American courts. Those failed because the courts did not consider themselves competent to decide on the matter.

Namibian lawyer Patrick Kauta’s law firm wrote to Attorney-General Festus Mbandeka and international relations minister Netumbo Nandi-Ndaitwah in September.

From the lawyers' point of view, the joint declaration violates constitutional and international law for various reasons. They highlighted rights of participation under customary international law as an example.

According to the United Nations Declaration on the Protection of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), the Namibian and German governments should have involved the affected groups in the negotiations "in a substantive manner and through self-elected representatives".

Furthermore, according to the declaration, the Namibian government agreed with the German government's argument that the crimes committed during the genocide did not constitute rights violations in the context of the time. The lawyers said this is backed by a "racist" distinction between "civilised" and "non-civilised" nations.

They also considered the abrupt termination – at the end of last year - of heated debates in Namibian parliament on the agreement unlawful. Until now, parliament's approval has not been necessary for the signing of the agreement.

‘Malicious allegations’

In a letter, Mbandeka rejected the lawyers’ objections.

He wrote of "malicious allegations" and "insinuations" that lacked any basis. Government rejected the "often-repeated false allegation" that the joint declaration was created without the participation and consultation of the affected communities, he said.

President Hage Geingob and government demonstrably approached the representatives to join the negotiation process, he argued, adding that the state remains open to further talks.

The president had the authority to conclude international treaties, he said.

Meanwhile, the German side sees it the same way.

"The Namibian government is and remains the negotiating partner," the German foreign office said in a response to the Left Party parliamentary group in August.

Hotly debated

Beyond participation in the talks, the type and amount of reparations continue to be hotly debated in Namibia.

According to the current plan, about N$18 billion (1.1 billion euros) is set to flow into development projects that will also benefit the victims' descendants.

The opposing Herero and Nama organisations, however, insisted on real reparation payments and significantly higher amounts.

A few days ago, the deputy governor of the Bank of Namibia Ebson Uanguta said over 70 billion euros would be appropriate, while a candidate for Ovaherero Paramount Chief position previously mentioned more than 800 billion euros.

The Namibian government is now coming under increasing pressure. Vice-President Nangolo Mbumba recently explained the current state of negotiations to more than 250 heads of various ethnic groups at a Chiefs Forum.

He said after the debates in parliament, government gave Germany a "supplementary proposal" in July. Among other things, Germany was to give assurances that the 1.1 billion euros was not the final amount and that additional payment would be negotiated in the future.

Disbursement should be flexible, he said, and payments should be brought forward to "mitigate the problem of attrition and value for money over the 30 years".

Where practical, the descendants of victims in the diaspora should also benefit from the programmes, he added.

Germany has yet to respond to this proposal.

Mbumba dismissed speculation that the two governments had already secretly signed the agreement. He said any signing would be done "openly and publicly".

Comments

Namibian Sun 2024-11-05

No comments have been left on this article

Please login to leave a comment

Premier League: Fulham 2 vs 1 Brentford | Manchester United 1 vs 1 Chelsea | Tottenham Hotspur 4 vs 1 Aston Villa | Wolves 2 vs 2 Crystal Palace | Southampton 1 vs 0 Everton | Nottingham Forest 3 vs 0 West Ham | Liverpool 2 vs 1 Brighton | Ipswich Town 1 vs 1 Leicester City | Bournemouth 2 vs 1 Manchester City | Newcastle 1 vs 0 Arsenal Katima Mulilo: 22° | 38° Rundu: 22° | 36° Eenhana: 20° | 36° Oshakati: 21° | 35° Ruacana: 20° | 36° Tsumeb: 24° | 33° Otjiwarongo: 18° | 33° Omaruru: 19° | 35° Windhoek: 17° | 33° Gobabis: 16° | 35° Henties Bay: 13° | 19° Wind speed: 21km/h, Wind direction: SW, Low tide: 10:52, High tide: 05:12, Low Tide: 23:16, High tide: 17:15 Swakopmund: 14° | 15° Wind speed: 18km/h, Wind direction: W, Low tide: 10:50, High tide: 05:10, Low Tide: 23:14, High tide: 17:13 Walvis Bay: 13° | 19° Wind speed: 21km/h, Wind direction: W, Low tide: 10:50, High tide: 05:09, Low Tide: 23:14, High tide: 17:12 Rehoboth: 15° | 35° Mariental: 14° | 35° Keetmanshoop: 13° | 33° Aranos: 14° | 36° Lüderitz: 15° | 29° Ariamsvlei: 10° | 30° Oranjemund: 15° | 31° Luanda: 25° | 26° Gaborone: 19° | 36° Lubumbashi: 17° | 32° Mbabane: 12° | 22° Maseru: 6° | 26° Antananarivo: 17° | 28° Lilongwe: 24° | 33° Maputo: 18° | 26° Windhoek: 17° | 33° Cape Town: 13° | 22° Durban: 15° | 20° Johannesburg: 16° | 29° Dar es Salaam: 25° | 31° Lusaka: 21° | 35° Harare: 19° | 31° Currency: GBP to NAD 22.58 | EUR to NAD 18.97 | CNY to NAD 2.44 | USD to NAD 17.37 | DZD to NAD 0.13 | AOA to NAD 0.02 | BWP to NAD 1.26 | EGP to NAD 0.34 | KES to NAD 0.13 | NGN to NAD 0.01 | ZMW to NAD 0.63 | ZWL to NAD 0.04 | BRL to NAD 3.01 | RUB to NAD 0.18 | INR to NAD 0.21 | USD to DZD 132.76 | USD to AOA 909.05 | USD to BWP 13.33 | USD to EGP 49.07 | USD to KES 129.2 | USD to NGN 1664.36 | USD to ZAR 17.38 | USD to ZMW 26.95 | USD to ZWL 321 | Stock Exchange: JSE All Share Index Same 0 | Namibian Stock Exchange (NSX) Overall Index 1876.57 Up +0.49% | Casablanca Stock Exchange (CSE) MASI 14300.12 Up +0.21% | Egyptian Exchange (EGX) 30 Index 30650.04 Down -0.59% | Botswana Stock Exchange (BSE) DCI 9845.11 Same 0 | NSX: MTC 7.75 SAME | Anirep 8.99 SAME | Capricorn Investment group 17.34 SAME | FirstRand Namibia Ltd 49 DOWN 0.50% | Letshego Holdings (Namibia) Ltd 4.1 UP 2.50% | Namibia Asset Management Ltd 0.7 SAME | Namibia Breweries Ltd 31.49 UP 0.03% | Nictus Holdings - Nam 2.22 SAME | Oryx Properties Ltd 12.1 UP 1.70% | Paratus Namibia Holdings 11.99 SAME | SBN Holdings 8.45 SAME | Trustco Group Holdings Ltd 0.48 SAME | B2Gold Corporation 47.34 DOWN 1.50% | Local Index closed 677.62 UP 0.12% | Overall Index closed 1534.6 DOWN 0.05% | Osino Resources Corp 19.47 DOWN 2.41% | Commodities: Gold US$ 2 743.51/OZ UP +0.27% | Copper US$ 4.45/lb UP +0.75% | Zinc US$ 3 126.30/T DOWN -0.16% | Brent Crude Oil US$ 75.96/BBP UP +0.49% | Platinum US$ 998.41/OZ UP +1.82% Sport results: Premier League: Fulham 2 vs 1 Brentford | Manchester United 1 vs 1 Chelsea | Tottenham Hotspur 4 vs 1 Aston Villa | Wolves 2 vs 2 Crystal Palace | Southampton 1 vs 0 Everton | Nottingham Forest 3 vs 0 West Ham | Liverpool 2 vs 1 Brighton | Ipswich Town 1 vs 1 Leicester City | Bournemouth 2 vs 1 Manchester City | Newcastle 1 vs 0 Arsenal Weather: Katima Mulilo: 22° | 38° Rundu: 22° | 36° Eenhana: 20° | 36° Oshakati: 21° | 35° Ruacana: 20° | 36° Tsumeb: 24° | 33° Otjiwarongo: 18° | 33° Omaruru: 19° | 35° Windhoek: 17° | 33° Gobabis: 16° | 35° Henties Bay: 13° | 19° Wind speed: 21km/h, Wind direction: SW, Low tide: 10:52, High tide: 05:12, Low Tide: 23:16, High tide: 17:15 Swakopmund: 14° | 15° Wind speed: 18km/h, Wind direction: W, Low tide: 10:50, High tide: 05:10, Low Tide: 23:14, High tide: 17:13 Walvis Bay: 13° | 19° Wind speed: 21km/h, Wind direction: W, Low tide: 10:50, High tide: 05:09, Low Tide: 23:14, High tide: 17:12 Rehoboth: 15° | 35° Mariental: 14° | 35° Keetmanshoop: 13° | 33° Aranos: 14° | 36° Lüderitz: 15° | 29° Ariamsvlei: 10° | 30° Oranjemund: 15° | 31° Luanda: 25° | 26° Gaborone: 19° | 36° Lubumbashi: 17° | 32° Mbabane: 12° | 22° Maseru: 6° | 26° Antananarivo: 17° | 28° Lilongwe: 24° | 33° Maputo: 18° | 26° Windhoek: 17° | 33° Cape Town: 13° | 22° Durban: 15° | 20° Johannesburg: 16° | 29° Dar es Salaam: 25° | 31° Lusaka: 21° | 35° Harare: 19° | 31° Economic Indicators: Currency: GBP to NAD 22.58 | EUR to NAD 18.97 | CNY to NAD 2.44 | USD to NAD 17.37 | DZD to NAD 0.13 | AOA to NAD 0.02 | BWP to NAD 1.26 | EGP to NAD 0.34 | KES to NAD 0.13 | NGN to NAD 0.01 | ZMW to NAD 0.63 | ZWL to NAD 0.04 | BRL to NAD 3.01 | RUB to NAD 0.18 | INR to NAD 0.21 | USD to DZD 132.76 | USD to AOA 909.05 | USD to BWP 13.33 | USD to EGP 49.07 | USD to KES 129.2 | USD to NGN 1664.36 | USD to ZAR 17.38 | USD to ZMW 26.95 | USD to ZWL 321 | Stock Exchange: JSE All Share Index Same 0 | Namibian Stock Exchange (NSX) Overall Index 1876.57 Up +0.49% | Casablanca Stock Exchange (CSE) MASI 14300.12 Up +0.21% | Egyptian Exchange (EGX) 30 Index 30650.04 Down -0.59% | Botswana Stock Exchange (BSE) DCI 9845.11 Same 0 | NSX: MTC 7.75 SAME | Anirep 8.99 SAME | Capricorn Investment group 17.34 SAME | FirstRand Namibia Ltd 49 DOWN 0.50% | Letshego Holdings (Namibia) Ltd 4.1 UP 2.50% | Namibia Asset Management Ltd 0.7 SAME | Namibia Breweries Ltd 31.49 UP 0.03% | Nictus Holdings - Nam 2.22 SAME | Oryx Properties Ltd 12.1 UP 1.70% | Paratus Namibia Holdings 11.99 SAME | SBN Holdings 8.45 SAME | Trustco Group Holdings Ltd 0.48 SAME | B2Gold Corporation 47.34 DOWN 1.50% | Local Index closed 677.62 UP 0.12% | Overall Index closed 1534.6 DOWN 0.05% | Osino Resources Corp 19.47 DOWN 2.41% | Commodities: Gold US$ 2 743.51/OZ UP +0.27% | Copper US$ 4.45/lb UP +0.75% | Zinc US$ 3 126.30/T DOWN -0.16% | Brent Crude Oil US$ 75.96/BBP UP +0.49% | Platinum US$ 998.41/OZ UP +1.82%