ANGULA VS NAMRA: Ally Angula. Photo: Contributed
ANGULA VS NAMRA: Ally Angula. Photo: Contributed

Angula takes N$26.7m tax fight with Namra to court

Sonja Smith

Businesswoman Ally Angula has approached the High Court seeking to have more than N$26.7 million recognised as tax deductions, including nearly N$24 million she says she advanced to keep Leap Holdings operating and protect herself from bankruptcy.

Angula wants the court to overturn decisions by the Namibia Revenue Agency (Namra) and the tax tribunal rejecting her deductions for the 2014, 2015 and 2016 tax years.

She says the advances covered salaries, suppliers and creditors after she personally guaranteed the company's debts, exposing herself to financial ruin when the business ran into difficulties.

The tribunal rejected her argument, finding that Leap Holdings was a separate taxpayer and that the advances did not qualify as deductions against income from her chartered accountancy practice.

Angula wants the High Court to set aside Namra's objection decision of 19 September 2025 and the tribunal's ruling of 4 August 2026 and uphold her original tax returns without referring the matter back for reassessment.

“I respectfully ask the court to declare the objection decision, and the tribunal's ruling to be unlawful and of no force or effect, and confirm and uphold my self-assessed returns, exactly as originally filed,” she said in her affidavit.

Near collapse

Angula served as managing director and shareholder of Leap Holdings (Pty) Ltd, with which she signed a loan agreement and a managing director founder agreement on 1 March 2013.

Under the loan agreement, she undertook to provide working capital for the company and its subsidiaries whenever required.

She maintains that the advances were not shareholder investments or capital contributions but funds necessary to keep the business operating.

“Working capital advances (N$23 981 092) were funded for employee salaries and wages, payments to operational creditors, supplier payments (feed, veterinary, fuel), utilities, rent, day-to-day operational expenses, and payments for interest on surety debt,” she said.

Angula argued that the N$23.98 million should qualify as deductible business expenditure because it prevented the company's immediate collapse.

“Without the advances, Leap Holdings would have collapsed immediately,” she said.

She also personally guaranteed the company's debts to third-party lenders and creditors, who pursued her when Leap Holdings became insolvent.

Angula said the guarantees exposed her to bankruptcy, threatened her professional registration and placed a finance ministry consultancy contract at risk.

The tribunal rejected the deductions, distinguishing between her professional accountancy practice and Leap Holdings as a separate registered taxpayer.

It found that advances made to the company as shareholder and managing director were not expenditures incurred in producing income from her accountancy practice.

“Can the taxpayer deduct the loan advances as bad debts? The taxpayer advanced her own funds to a separate tax entity,” the tribunal wrote.

Other expenses rejected

Namra's audit findings letter, dated 22 April 2024 and seen by Namibian Sun, lists N$26 753 462 in disallowed expenses across the three tax years, mainly involving bad debts.

In 2014, Namra disallowed approximately N$4.6 million in bad-debt-related expenses, N$213 398 in trade-related motor vehicle expenses and N$141 766 in farming expenses.

The corresponding amounts for 2015 were N$14 million, N$213 398 and N$141 766, while the 2016 figures were approximately N$6.6 million, N$251 413 and N$141 766, respectively.

Risk exposure

Namra maintained that the motor vehicle expenses and bad-debt claims did not qualify for deductions under sections 17(1) and 24(g) of the Income Tax Act.

Angula also disputes the rejection of N$1 668 857 in interest and related expenses, including costs associated with personal suretyships, storage, insurance, legal services and her former KPMG partnership.

She said creditors pursued her personally after Leap Holdings defaulted, forcing her to service the debts to avoid judgments and bankruptcy proceedings.

“I was exposed to a direct and immediate risk of personal bankruptcy,” she said.

Angula argues that the expenses were necessary to preserve her professional income and should not have been treated as personal or capital expenditure.

Angula also accuses Namra of incorrectly classifying her professional earnings as employment income rather than income from independent consultancy work.

She said she practised as a chartered accountant on her own account, served on corporate boards and provided consultancy services, including to the finance ministry.

According to Angula, the classification resulted in the rejection of legitimate trade deductions.

The dispute also covers farming expenses and capital allowances claimed for a tractor.

Namra rejected the claims because it found no farming activity during the assessment years, despite Angula maintaining that Leap Holdings operated a horticultural and agricultural venture with employees and an operations manager, and that the tractor was used during the business's start-up phase.

The tribunal found that she had not provided sufficient documentation to substantiate the farming expenses and capital allowances.

Angula argues that Namra's decisions were affected by administrative failures, incorrect income classification and the rejection of legitimate business expenditure.


 

Comments

Namibian Sun 2026-11-21

No comments have been left on this article

Please login to leave a comment